Home / Apartments / Islamorada

Islamorada Apartment Complexes — Pros & Cons From Real Resident Reviews

1 communities reviewed · Updated Jul 2026

Islamorada is a Florida Keys village spread across six islands, built around sport fishing, diving, and boating rather than a conventional job center. Its rental market is dominated almost entirely by single-family homes and individually owned condo units — often geared toward vacation or seasonal rental — rather than large, professionally managed apartment complexes.

As of mid-2026, there is essentially no traditional apartment-complex inventory in Islamorada; renters instead compete for individually listed houses and condo units, where 2-bedroom units commonly range from roughly $2,800 to $7,500+/month depending on waterfront access and finish level.

Plantation Key (1)

Quick comparison

ComplexNeighborhood BedsAdvertised rentsBuilt
Plantation By The SeaPlantation Key2 BR$2,850-$2,9001977

Rents are approximate, from public listings at review time — confirm with the property.

Plantation Key

Plantation By The Sea
2 BR · $2,850-$2,900
✓ Genuine oceanfront setting on Millionaire's Row in Plantation Key, with a shared pool, 300-foot fishing pier, and boat dock — resort-style extras rare at this price point in the Keys
✕ This is a condominium association with individually owned units rented out by separate landlords, not a single professionally managed apartment complex — quality, pricing, and responsiveness vary unit to unit
Full pros & cons →

Florida renter essentials

Renters insurance is not optional here. Most Florida leases require it, and standard policies do NOT cover flood damage — that needs a separate flood policy, even in an apartment. Before signing, look up the building's flood zone on FEMA's flood map service and ask which evacuation zone it sits in.

Ask about the real monthly cost. The most common complaint in Florida apartment reviews isn't noise — it's fee stacking: valet trash, common-area electric, mandatory bulk internet, pest control, admin and tech fees. Get the full itemized monthly figure in writing before you apply.

Tour with the AC running and ask about hurricanes. Humidity control is the difference between a fine unit and a moldy one; ask how old the AC is. And ask directly how the building handled the last major storm — communities that performed well say so happily, and reviewers call out the ones that didn't.

About these pros & cons How we build these pages: we read publicly available resident reviews (Google, ApartmentRatings, Yelp, Reddit and similar) for each community and summarize the recurring themes in our own words. We don't copy review text, we don't display star ratings we didn't compute, and no complex has paid to appear or to have anything removed. Cons reflect what residents report — experiences vary. Rent ranges come from public listings and change often; always confirm current pricing, fees and policies with the property directly.

Moving to Islamorada?

Once you've picked a place, our Islamorada directory covers the rest of the move — movers, internet, utilities setup, and every home service you'll need.

Islamorada home services → Florida relocation guide → Cost estimator →