Plantation By The Sea Apartments: Rent, Trade-offs & Resident Feedback
Plantation Key · Islamorada, FL · Our summary of recurring themes in public resident feedback, plus property details and advertised rent. Updated Jul 2026.
Quick take on Plantation By The Sea
Plantation By The Sea is an oceanfront condo community on Plantation Key with a shared pool, boat dock, and fitness center, where individual 2-bedroom units are rented out by private owners rather than a single management company. It's the closest thing to an apartment community actually operating within Islamorada, but renters should expect condo-association variability rather than centralized property management.
Track Plantation By The Sea and similar apartments
Tell us what you need. We use renter requests to prioritize fresh research for Islamorada and may email you when we add relevant profiles or verified availability.
What residents like
- ✓Genuine oceanfront setting on Millionaire's Row in Plantation Key, with a shared pool, 300-foot fishing pier, and boat dock — resort-style extras rare at this price point in the Keys
- ✓Individual units are privately owned and rented out furnished, so turnkey, move-in-ready availability is common
- ✓Walking distance to Founders Park, shops, and restaurants, a rarity in a car-dependent stretch of the Overseas Highway
Common complaints
- The available public review sample did not provide enough recurring resident complaint detail to summarize responsibly.
Resident reviews of Plantation By The Sea
Written by people who say they live or lived here. Reviews are moderated for relevance and safety; payment and property partnerships never affect what gets published. Read our review standards.
Loading resident reviews…
Reviews are taking a little longer to load
Your connection may have dropped. The apartment research above is still available.
Be the first resident to share the real story
Your experience with maintenance, management, noise and day-to-day living can help the next Florida renter make a smarter decision.
Amenities
We cross-check property information and summarize recurring public resident feedback. A missing detail means we could not verify it reliably—not that the fee, rule or feature does not exist.
Report outdated property information
Tell us about a changed rent, fee, policy, amenity or management company. We verify submissions against public sources before editing a profile.
Questions to ask when you tour Plantation By The Sea
Use these questions to verify current conditions and investigate the trade-offs surfaced by public resident feedback.
- What is the exact monthly total after every mandatory fee, utility package and service charge?
- Can I see the specific available unit—not only the model—and receive the quoted price in writing?
- How does guest parking work, and what rules can lead to towing?
- Who handles after-hours maintenance emergencies, and what response time is promised in the lease?
- How often has the access gate or controlled-entry system been unavailable during the past year?
- Which advertised amenities are currently open, what are their hours, and is access included in base rent?
- Who is the current management company, and how are unresolved resident issues escalated?
Own or manage this community? Verify factual details or view partner options. Sponsorship never changes our resident-feedback summaries.