Typical other services: Furniture assembly, Drywall repair, Minor plumbing, +4 more
The 30-Second Verdict
Mr. Appliance (a Neighborly franchise) is the local-operator model: upfront flat-rate quotes before work starts, techs in your metro whose reviews you can actually check, no overtime charges, and a parts-and-labor warranty through the Neighborly Done Right Promise. Sears Home Services is the legacy giant — it repairs most brands and remains one of the few realistic options for Kenmore — but years of corporate turbulence show up as wide appointment windows, day-of cancellations, and long part-order waits in many Florida markets. Service call fees are similar ($90–$130, usually credited toward the repair). For most Florida homeowners, a well-reviewed Mr. Appliance territory (or a strong independent) is the more reliable booking; choose Sears when you have Kenmore equipment, an active Sears protection agreement, or a manufacturer warranty routed through them.
Head-to-Head Breakdown
Mr. Appliance
Pros
- Upfront flat-rate pricing quoted before work begins
- Local franchise accountability — your metro's reviews are meaningful
- No overtime or trip surcharges for standard scheduling
- Parts + labor warranty (Neighborly Done Right Promise)
- Usually tighter arrival windows and faster first appointments
Cons
- Franchise coverage gaps in rural Florida
- High-end/built-in brands (Sub-Zero, Thermador) referred out by some territories
- Parts still subject to distributor delays
- Territory quality varies — check your city's reviews
Sears Home Services
Pros
- Repairs most major brands; deepest Kenmore expertise anywhere
- Nationwide infrastructure — serves nearly every Florida zip
- Protection agreements/home warranties can cover repairs fully
- 90-day parts and labor guarantee standard
- Online scheduling with diagnostic pre-screening
Cons
- Wide appointment windows and a reputation for reschedules/cancellations
- Part-ordering can stretch repairs across weeks
- Corporate churn has thinned tech ranks in some Florida markets
- Upsell of protection agreements at the door
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Mr. Appliance | Sears Home Services | |
|---|---|---|
| Model | Local franchise (Neighborly) | National corporate service |
| Service call fee (FL) | $90–$120, credited to repair | $99–$129, credited to repair |
| Typical repair total | $180–$450 | $200–$450 |
| Warranty on work | Done Right Promise (parts+labor) | 90-day parts + labor |
| Kenmore expertise | General | Best available |
| Scheduling reliability | Generally strong | Inconsistent by market |
| High-end built-ins | Varies by territory | Limited |
| Best for | Most out-of-warranty repairs | Kenmore + protection agreements |
Frequently Asked Questions
Is the repair even worth it?
Rule of thumb: repair if the fix is under half the replacement cost and the appliance is in the first half of its lifespan (refrigerators 10–15 yrs, washers 8–12, dryers 10–13, dishwashers 8–10). A $300 repair on a 12-year-old fridge is usually money down the drain; the same repair on a 4-year-old unit is a clear yes.
What does the service call fee cover?
The tech's trip and diagnosis — typically $90–$130 in Florida, credited toward the repair if you proceed. Both companies apply it that way. Getting two diagnoses costs you one extra fee and is worth it on repairs quoted above $350.
Why is Florida hard on appliances?
Humidity corrodes boards and connections, salt air accelerates it near the coast, lightning-season power surges kill control boards, and garage-installed refrigerators fight 100°F ambient heat. Surge protectors on major appliances ($30–$60) are the cheapest insurance available — most control-board deaths here are surge-related.
Should I use the manufacturer's service instead?
In warranty, yes — always route through the manufacturer first (Whirlpool, GE, LG, Samsung all have factory-service networks in Florida metros, and Sears/Mr. Appliance both take some factory-authorized work). Out of warranty, factory service usually costs more than either company here for the same fix.
Are home warranties (AHS, Choice) a better way to handle this?
They shift repairs to a $75–$125 trade call fee, but you lose control: the warranty company picks the contractor and decides repair-vs-replace, and payout caps apply. If you keep appliances long past warranty and dislike surprise bills, they have a place — see our American Home Shield vs Choice comparison for the details.
Top-Rated Local Florida Other Services Alternatives
You don't have to pick a national brand. These Florida-based other services companies have the highest real Google ratings in our directory — often at a fraction of the franchise price.
Mission Pest Solutions
ClaimTypical other services: Service consultations, Custom quotes, Local service area
Fix My Computer On Site
ClaimTypical other services: Furniture assembly, Drywall repair, Minor plumbing, +4 more
Custom Pest Solutions
ClaimTypical other services: Service consultations, Custom quotes, Local service area
Contractor Source
ClaimTypical other services: Service consultations, Custom quotes, Local service area
5 Star Pro Wash LLC
ClaimTypical other services: Service consultations, Custom quotes, Local service area