Don Bailey Carpets
ClaimServices: Tile installation, Hardwood install, Luxury vinyl plank, +3 more
The 30-Second Verdict
Floor & Decor is the warehouse giant — massive selection of wood-look porcelain tile and luxury vinyl plank at 30-50% below boutique pricing. The Tile Shop is a design-forward boutique with premium materials, designer assistance, and higher-end stone and glass tile. For value-conscious Florida buyers doing full-house tile or LVP projects, Floor & Decor wins on price and product depth. For kitchen backsplash, custom bathrooms, or designer material sourcing, The Tile Shop's curated selection and design consultation is worth the premium.
Head-to-Head Breakdown
Floor & Decor
Pros
- Warehouse pricing — 30-50% cheaper than boutiques on comparable tile
- Widest in-stock selection of wood-look porcelain and LVP in Florida
- In-store pro desk for contractor pricing and project management
- Multiple FL locations including Tampa, Orlando, Miami, Jacksonville
- No minimum order — buy what you need, return unused full boxes
Cons
- Warehouse setting — limited design assistance vs boutique retailers
- Overwhelming for first-time buyers without a contractor guiding selection
- Higher-end stone and specialty glass tile selection is limited
The Tile Shop
Pros
- Designer-quality materials including marble, glass mosaic, and handmade tile
- Complimentary design consultation in-store
- Product is pre-curated — easier to find cohesive coordinated collections
- Better representation of on-trend Florida coastal aesthetic (bleached wood, travertine)
Cons
- Significantly higher prices — comparable tile runs 40-80% more than F&D
- Fewer Florida locations — major metros only
- Smaller LVP / rigid core plank selection vs Floor & Decor
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Floor & Decor | The Tile Shop | |
|---|---|---|
| Store Type | Warehouse (big box) | Boutique (design-forward) |
| Wood-Look Porcelain Tile (sq ft) | $1.99 – $5.99/sq ft | $5.99 – $18+/sq ft |
| LVP Selection | Extensive (50+ options) | Limited |
| Design Consultation | Basic (pro desk) | Complimentary design service |
| FL Store Availability | 11+ locations statewide | Select major markets |
| Best For | Whole-house projects; value buyers | Custom baths; designer kitchens |
Frequently Asked Questions
What flooring is best for Florida homes?
Porcelain tile is the top recommendation for Florida — impervious to humidity, moisture, and insects. Wood-look porcelain plank (10x60" or 12x72") mimics hardwood without any of the moisture risk. Luxury vinyl plank (LVP) is the #2 choice — waterproof, comfortable, and significantly cheaper than tile. Real hardwood is risky in FL — humidity cycles cause expansion and cupping.
Is travertine flooring good for Florida homes?
Travertine is popular in Florida for its natural look and feel, but it's porous and requires annual sealing in FL humidity. Unsealed travertine will absorb moisture and stain. Polished travertine tiles are also slippery when wet — a hazard near pools and bathrooms. Many FL designers now recommend porcelain tiles that mimic travertine at lower maintenance cost.
How much does tile installation cost in Florida?
Tile installation (labor only) averages $5-$10/sq ft in Florida for standard 12x12 or 12x24 field tile. Large-format tiles (24x48 or 12x72) require more skill and run $8-$14/sq ft labor. Full bathroom tile including demo, cement board, and material runs $1,500-$4,000+ for a typical FL master bath.
Top-Rated Local Florida Flooring Alternatives
You don't have to pick a national brand. These Florida-based flooring companies have the highest real Google ratings in our directory — often at a fraction of the franchise price.
FLOCO Decking Systems
ClaimServices: Tile installation, Hardwood install, Luxury vinyl plank, +3 more
Services: Tile installation, Hardwood install, Luxury vinyl plank, +3 more
Services: Tile installation, Hardwood install, Luxury vinyl plank, +3 more
Indian River Flooring
ClaimServices: Tile installation, Hardwood install, Luxury vinyl plank, +3 more
Royal Rug and Flooring
ClaimServices: Tile installation, Hardwood install, Luxury vinyl plank, +3 more