The 30-Second Verdict
For long-distance moves to Florida, Penske typically wins — newer trucks, unlimited mileage on one-ways, and better fuel economy offset the higher base rate. For local FL moves or short notice, U-Haul's massive location network is hard to beat. Book either as far in advance as possible; Florida's winter moving season (Nov–April) sees trucks sell out weeks ahead.
Head-to-Head Breakdown
U-Haul
Pros
- Largest truck rental network in Florida
- Lower base rental rates
- More drop-off locations across FL
- Towing equipment widely available
Cons
- Older fleet — more mechanical issues reported
- Mileage charges add up on long drives
- Reservation not-honored complaints are common
Penske
Pros
- Newer fleet — more reliable, cleaner trucks
- Unlimited mileage on most one-way rentals
- Better fuel economy = lower total trip cost
- Higher customer satisfaction ratings
Cons
- Higher base rental rate
- Fewer locations — especially outside major FL cities
- No small cargo van option
Side-by-Side Comparison
| U-Haul | Penske | |
|---|---|---|
| Fleet Age/Condition | Older fleet on average; hit-or-miss truck condition at some locations | Newer fleet — trucks average 3–5 years old; more consistent quality |
| Truck Sizes | 10', 15', 20', 26' + pickup trucks and cargo vans | 12', 16', 22', 26' — no small van option |
| One-Way Rentals | Available; many drop-off locations across FL | Available; fewer FL drop locations than U-Haul |
| Pricing | Lower base rate; mileage and fuel charges add up significantly | Higher base rate but unlimited mileage on most one-way rentals |
| Fuel Policy | Return full; no prepay option; less fuel-efficient trucks | Return full; trucks are more fuel-efficient (better gas mileage) |
| Availability | Largest network — locations in virtually every FL city | Strong but fewer locations; mostly major cities and highways |
| Customer Reviews | Mixed — reservations sometimes not honored, older equipment | Consistently higher customer ratings; more reliable reservations |
| Towing | Auto transport and tow dollies widely available | Car towing available at many locations |
Frequently Asked Questions
When is the best time to rent a moving truck for a Florida move?
Avoid January–March peak season if possible. Summer (June–August) has more availability and lower prices, though you'll be moving in Florida's hottest months.
Can I do a one-way rental from another state to Florida?
Yes — both U-Haul and Penske offer one-way interstate rentals. Penske's unlimited mileage policy makes it particularly cost-effective for long-distance moves.
What size truck do I need for a 3-bedroom house?
A 26-foot truck (both brands) comfortably fits a 3–4 bedroom home. For a 2BR apartment, a 20-foot U-Haul or 22-foot Penske works well.