The 30-Second Verdict
Hurricane shutters are far superior to plywood — they qualify for insurance discounts, require no labor before each storm, and provide significantly better protection. Plywood is a last-resort option, not a comparable alternative.
Head-to-Head Breakdown
Hurricane Shutters
Pros
- Qualifies for Florida wind mitigation insurance discounts ($500–$2,000/year)
- Ready to deploy in minutes — no hardware store runs before storms
- Meets Miami-Dade NOA standards for tested wind protection
- Multiple options: accordion (most convenient), roll-down (automated), panel
- Permanent investment that adds to home value
- Available for all opening types including doors and skylights
Cons
- High upfront cost — $10,000–$25,000 for whole-house protection
- Accordion and roll-down shutters require professional installation
- Panel shutters require physical installation before each storm
- Reduces natural light when deployed
- Requires maintenance — lubrication, cleaning, and occasional repair
Plywood Boarding
Pros
- Very low material cost — plywood runs $20–$50 per sheet
- Available at hardware stores (though often sold out pre-storm)
- Can be stored flat in garage between uses
Cons
- Does NOT qualify for insurance discounts
- Labor-intensive — requires cutting, drilling, and hanging before every storm
- Hardware stores often run out of plywood before major storms
- Does NOT meet Florida Building Code as an approved opening protection
- Degrades with each use — warps, splits, and loses effectiveness
- Offers no protection against flying debris penetrating the wood itself
- Disposal challenge after each use
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Hurricane Shutters | Plywood Boarding | |
|---|---|---|
| Factor | Hurricane Shutters | Plywood |
| Insurance discount | Yes ($500–$2,000/yr) | No |
| Upfront cost (whole house) | $10,000–$25,000 | $500–$2,000 materials + labor |
| Storm prep time | 15–60 minutes | 4–12+ hours |
| FL Building Code compliant | Yes (approved products) | No |
| Repeated use | Indefinite | Degrades after 1–3 uses |
| Payback via insurance | 5–15 years | Never |
| Debris protection | Tested/rated | Untested/unrated |
| Availability pre-storm | Always ready | Often sold out |
Frequently Asked Questions
question
answer
question
answer
question
answer