Home / Compare / Asphalt Shingles vs Metal Roof

Asphalt Shingles vs. Metal vs. Tile Roof in Florida: Full Comparison

Updated for 2026 · Roofing · verified Florida pricing + warranty details

By the I'm Moving to Florida Editorial Team · Last reviewed May 23, 2026

The 30-Second Verdict

Tile is the premium long-term choice in South/Central Florida; metal is the best value for hurricane resistance and longevity in all of Florida; asphalt shingles are cheapest upfront but require replacement more frequently in Florida's climate.

Head-to-Head Breakdown

Asphalt Shingles

Pros

  • Lowest upfront cost — $8,000–$18,000 for typical Florida home
  • Wide availability — any Florida roofer can install
  • Easy to repair individual shingles
  • Significant improvements in wind ratings (impact-resistant shingles available)
  • Florida Building Code-compliant options available

Cons

  • Shortest lifespan in Florida — 15–20 years vs. 40–50+ for metal/tile
  • Higher insurance premiums than metal or tile on many Florida policies
  • Least hurricane-resistant of the three options
  • Must be replaced more frequently, increasing lifetime cost
Metal Roof

Pros

  • Excellent hurricane resistance — standing seam metal is Category 5 rated
  • Long lifespan — 40–70 years
  • Lower insurance premiums vs. asphalt on many Florida policies
  • Reflects Florida sun — improves energy efficiency
  • Lightweight — no structural reinforcement usually needed
  • Fastest growing roofing type in Florida

Cons

  • Higher upfront cost than asphalt — $15,000–$35,000 installed
  • Can be noisy during Florida rain and hail
  • Not traditional Florida aesthetic in some markets
📍 View Metal Roof listing ↗

Side-by-Side Comparison

Asphalt ShinglesMetal Roof
FactorAsphalt ShinglesMetal (Standing Seam)
Florida installed cost$8,000–$18,000$15,000–$35,000
Florida lifespan15–20 years40–70 years
Hurricane resistanceFair–GoodExcellent
Insurance impactStandardMay reduce premium
Energy efficiencyPoor–FairExcellent (reflective)
Aesthetic optionsManyModern/Contemporary
Weight (per sq ft)2–4 lbs1–2 lbs
FL market popularityNorth FL primarilyRapidly growing

Frequently Asked Questions

question
answer
question
answer
question
answer

Top-Rated Local Florida Roofing Alternatives

You don't have to pick a national brand. These Florida-based roofing companies have the highest real Google ratings in our directory — often at a fraction of the franchise price.

See all Florida Roofing pros →

Other Florida Brand Comparisons

LeafFilter vs LeafGuard
Gutter Protection
Bath Fitter vs Re-Bath
Remodeling
Window World vs Renewal by Andersen
Hurricane Shutters