The 30-Second Verdict
Both are national home warranty companies with large Florida presences — First American is known for better HVAC coverage, Choice for lower upfront pricing. Florida's demanding climate makes HVAC coverage quality the critical differentiator.
Head-to-Head Breakdown
First American Home Warranty
Pros
- Strong HVAC coverage — critical for Florida where AC runs 10–11 months/year
- Premier Plan covers additional items: roof leak repair, code violations
- Established since 1984 — one of the oldest home warranty companies
- Available in all 67 Florida counties
- Refrigerant (Freon/Puron) covered on some plans — expensive in Florida
- Generally higher satisfaction ratings for HVAC claims in Florida
Cons
- More expensive than Choice ($55–$75/month vs. Choice's $40–$55/month)
- Service call fee ($75–$125) on top of monthly premium
- Some exclusions for pre-existing conditions can be contested
- Customer service response times vary by region
Choice Home Warranty
Pros
- More affordable monthly premium — typically $40–$55/month
- Basic Plan and Total Plan are clearly structured and easy to compare
- No home inspection required to enroll
- Available for Florida homes regardless of age
- Marketing partnerships often include discounts for real estate transactions
Cons
- HVAC coverage caps and exclusions more limiting than First American
- Florida BBB complaints higher than industry average for some claim types
- Contractors in network vary in quality by Florida market
- Pre-existing condition language applied broadly in some denied claims
Side-by-Side Comparison
| First American Home Warranty | Choice Home Warranty | |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly cost (Basic) | $50–$65/month | $40–$55/month |
| Service call fee | $75–$125 | $85–$100 |
| HVAC coverage | Strong — refrigerant often included | Moderate — caps apply |
| Roof leak coverage | Available on Premier Plan | Not standard |
| Florida BBB rating | A+ | B (varies by state) |
| Waiting period | 30 days | 30 days |
| Contract term | Annual | Annual |
| Best for Florida | Older homes with AC as top priority | Newer homes, budget-focused |
Frequently Asked Questions
q
a
q
a
q
a