The 30-Second Verdict
CertaPro Painters and Five Star Painting are both national franchise painting companies with strong Florida presence. Both use subcontractor models and charge premium prices relative to local independent painters. CertaPro is the largest painting franchise in North America and has broader FL coverage; Five Star is growing quickly and competitive on price. For Florida exterior work specifically, ask any contractor about their exterior paint specification for Florida's UV and humidity conditions — that matters more than the brand name.
Head-to-Head Breakdown
CertaPro Painters
Pros
- Largest painting franchise — most FL locations
- Strong brand accountability system
- Detailed written estimates standard
Cons
- Premium pricing vs independent painters
- Subcontractor model means crew quality varies
Five Star Painting
Pros
- Competitive pricing relative to CertaPro
- Growing brand with motivated new franchise owners
- Often more responsive at quote stage
Cons
- Fewer FL locations than CertaPro
- Less established track record in FL market
Side-by-Side Comparison
| CertaPro Painters | Five Star Painting | |
|---|---|---|
| Business Model | Franchise — local franchise owners; national brand support | Franchise — locally owned and operated; growing national footprint |
| Interior & Exterior | Both; strong exterior paint expertise marketed for FL homes | Both; interior more marketed in some FL markets |
| Paint Used | Uses customer-choice paints including Sherwin-Williams and Benjamin Moore; quote specifies product | Typically Sherwin-Williams products; some franchises offer choice |
| Warranty | Typically 2–5 year workmanship warranty; varies by franchise | Typically 2 year warranty; varies by local franchise |
| Pricing | Premium pricing — $3,000–$6,000 for typical FL exterior repaint | Competitive franchise pricing — $2,500–$5,500 for typical FL exterior |
| FL Coverage | Extensive — most FL metros and many mid-size cities | Growing FL presence — strong in major metros, expanding |
| Crew Model | Primarily subcontractor model; quality varies by franchise | Mix of employees and subs depending on franchise |
| Reviews | Generally positive; quality highly dependent on local franchise owner | Generally positive; newer franchise with fewer long-term FL reviews |
Frequently Asked Questions
q
a
q
a
q
a