The 30-Second Verdict
Schlage Encode replaces the entire lockset and is more durable in Florida's salt air and humidity. August Smart Lock retrofits over your existing deadbolt — easier to install but more exposed to Florida's outdoor conditions. For coastal Florida homes, vacation rentals, or maximum durability, Schlage Encode is the better choice. For renters or those wanting to keep existing hardware, August is convenient.
Head-to-Head Breakdown
Schlage Encode
Pros
- Grade 1 security (commercial grade)
- Built-in keypad — no phone needed for entry
- Weatherproof design for FL outdoor use
- Works with Alexa, Google, Apple HomeKit
Cons
- More expensive ($250–$350)
- Requires full lockset replacement (professional install recommended)
- Heavier/bulkier design
August Smart Lock
Pros
- Installs over existing deadbolt in minutes
- App-based — great for vacation rental management
- Remote access control (give codes to guests)
- Lower cost ($150–$230)
Cons
- Interior-facing thumb-turn exposed, not weatherproof
- Phone required for some features (less convenient for guests)
- Battery life shorter (3–6 months)
- Less weather-resistant than Schlage for FL conditions
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Schlage Encode | August Smart Lock | |
|---|---|---|
| Installation | Replace full lockset (30 min) | Retrofit over existing deadbolt (5 min) |
| Security Grade | ANSI Grade 1 (commercial) | Grade 2 equivalent |
| Keypad | Built-in keypad (no phone needed) | Keypad model available (August Keypad) |
| Weather Rating | IP65 weatherproof | Interior-focused (limited outdoor exposure) |
| Vacation Rental | Multiple codes + scheduling | Full guest management via app |
| Price | $250–$350 | $150–$230 |
| Battery Life | Up to 6 months (4 AA) | 3–6 months (4 AA) |
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best smart lock for a Florida vacation rental?
August Smart Lock Pro or Schlage Encode Plus are both popular for Florida vacation rentals. Both support unlimited guest codes with scheduling (auto-expire codes) and remote management. For high-turnover Airbnb/VRBO properties, the ability to set unique codes per guest that expire automatically is the critical feature. Schlage's weatherproof construction gives it an edge for Florida outdoor conditions.
Do smart locks work in Florida's humidity and salt air?
Salt air is corrosive to electronic components. For coastal Florida homes (within a mile of salt water), specify locks with IP65 weatherproof ratings and stainless hardware. Schlage Encode's solid construction handles coastal conditions well. August Smart Lock's mechanism faces more corrosion risk in salt air environments — inspect annually and replace batteries every 6 months minimum in coastal settings.
Should I rekey or replace locks when buying a Florida home?
Always rekey or replace locks when purchasing a Florida home — you have no way to know how many keys the previous owner distributed. Rekeying costs $15–$30 per lock (locksmith); smart lock installation ($150–$350) simultaneously upgrades security and adds remote access capability. This is one of the most cost-effective home security improvements.