The 30-Second Verdict
Penske trucks are generally newer, better maintained, and have unlimited mileage on most one-way rentals — a significant advantage for long Florida moves. U-Haul has more locations in Florida (important for drop-off convenience) and lower base rates, but their trucks are older on average. For a long one-way move into Florida, Penske's unlimited mileage and newer fleet often make it worth the premium.
Head-to-Head Breakdown
U-Haul
Pros
- Most locations in Florida (convenient pickup/drop-off)
- Lower base rates
- Wide truck size availability
- Easy online booking
Cons
- Older fleet on average than Penske
- Mileage charges on many rentals
- Mixed customer service experience
- Local one-way fees can be high
Penske
Pros
- Newer, better-maintained fleet
- Unlimited mileage on most one-way rentals
- Free use of appliance dolly
- Better GPS and safety features
Cons
- Fewer Florida locations than U-Haul
- Higher base daily rate
- Less availability for last-minute bookings
- Smaller size selection in some markets
Side-by-Side Comparison
| U-Haul | Penske | |
|---|---|---|
| FL Location Count | Most extensive network | Fewer locations |
| Fleet Age | Older average fleet | Newer average fleet |
| One-Way Mileage | Charged per mile on most | Unlimited on most one-way rentals |
| 10' Truck (3 days est.) | $90–$180 + mileage | $130–$220 (often unlimited mileage) |
| Free Equipment | Furniture pads extra | Appliance dolly included |
| Reservation Changes | Easy online changes | Easy online changes |
| Best For | Short local moves, many drop points | Long-distance moves to/within FL |
Frequently Asked Questions
q
a
q
a
q
a