The 30-Second Verdict
PGT is Florida's largest and most recognized impact window manufacturer; CGI is a strong alternative with competitive pricing and excellent Miami-Dade NOA approval. Both are excellent choices.
Head-to-Head Breakdown
PGT Innovations
Pros
- Florida's #1 impact window brand by market share
- WinGuard product line is the industry standard in Florida
- Miami-Dade NOA approval on all hurricane-rated products
- Widest dealer and installer network in the state
- Made in Florida — Venice, FL headquarters and manufacturing
Cons
- Premium pricing due to market dominance
- Some homeowners report lead times during peak demand
- Brand premium sometimes not justified vs. CGI on value tier
CGI Windows & Doors
Pros
- Competitive pricing — often 10-20% below PGT for comparable specs
- Excellent Miami-Dade High-Velocity Hurricane Zone (HVHZ) approvals
- Sentinel by CGI product line is highly regarded
- Strong South Florida dealer presence where HVHZ code is strictest
- Good aesthetic options — clean sightlines on framing
Cons
- Smaller installer network outside South Florida
- Less brand recognition can affect resale perception (though performance is equivalent)
- Some dealers push PGT due to established relationships
Side-by-Side Comparison
| PGT Innovations | CGI Windows & Doors | |
|---|---|---|
| Florida Headquarters | Venice, FL | Miami, FL |
| Miami-Dade NOA | Yes (all hurricane products) | Yes (all hurricane products) |
| HVHZ Approval | Yes | Yes |
| Top Product Line | WinGuard | Sentinel |
| Impact Glass | Laminated (PVB interlayer) | Laminated (SGP interlayer options) |
| Frame Materials | Aluminum, vinyl, composite | Aluminum, vinyl |
| Florida Dealer Network | Statewide — very wide | Strong in South FL, growing statewide |
| Price Range (double-hung, installed) | $800–$1,800/window | $700–$1,600/window |
Frequently Asked Questions
q
a
q
a
q
a