The 30-Second Verdict
PGT and CGI are Florida-made and Florida-tested impact window brands — both are excellent choices. Andersen's impact line is well-built but costs more and is less Florida-optimized than the homegrown brands.
Head-to-Head Breakdown
PGT Innovations
Pros
- Made in Florida — engineered for Florida code and conditions
- Widest Florida contractor network
- WinGuard line rated to 200+ mph
- Competitive pricing vs. premium brands
Cons
- Aluminum frames — not as energy efficient as fiberglass
- Some models have limited style options vs. national brands
- Mid-range aesthetics vs. premium alternatives
CGI Windows & Doors
Pros
- Florida-manufactured in Miami — strong local code knowledge
- Excellent build quality — strong contractor reputation
- Wide range of impact products including sliding glass doors
- Strong dealer relationships in South Florida
Cons
- Smaller geographic distribution vs. PGT in some FL markets
- Less marketing/brand recognition than PGT
- Pricing comparable to PGT — not a budget option
Side-by-Side Comparison
| PGT Innovations | CGI Windows & Doors | |
|---|---|---|
| Manufacturing Location | North Venice, FL | Miami, FL |
| Wind Rating | Up to 200+ mph (WinGuard) | Up to 200+ mph |
| Frame Material | Aluminum | Aluminum |
| Cost (per window installed) | $500–$900 | $550–$950 |
| Warranty | Limited lifetime (original owner) | Limited lifetime (original owner) |
| Florida Contractor Network | Largest statewide | Strong in South/Central FL |
| NOA (Notice of Acceptance) | Miami-Dade approved | Miami-Dade approved |
| Best For | Statewide, best contractor availability | South Florida, premium product performance |
Frequently Asked Questions
Are PGT windows worth the price in Florida?
Yes — PGT's WinGuard aluminum impact windows are consistently rated among the best by Florida contractors for performance, availability, and warranty support. They're not the cheapest but represent strong value for the price.
Do impact windows eliminate the need for shutters in Florida?
Yes — Miami-Dade County NOA-approved impact windows satisfy Florida's opening protection requirements. You do not need shutters if your impact windows are properly installed and certified. This is a major convenience advantage for impact windows vs. shutter systems.